History of post ‘Four Great Debates in Science, Retold on Veritula’

Versions are sorted from most recent to oldest with the original version at the bottom. Changes are highlighted relative to the next, i.e. older, version underneath. Only changed lines and their surrounding lines are shown, except for the original version, which is shown in full.

Revision 1 · · View this (the most recent) version (v2)

Describe images for screen readers and search engines.

@@ -58,21 +58,21 @@ Set your passkey at <https://veritula.com/users/edit>

Authors can mark ideas as AI-assisted with a checkbox.

-![AI-assisted 1](/assets/veritula-ai-checkbox.png)
-![AI-assisted 2](/assets/veritula-ai-label.png)+![The ‘Text written with AI?’ checkbox when writing an idea](/assets/veritula-ai-checkbox.png)
+![An idea labeled ‘AI-assisted’, with the tooltip ‘The author says they used AI to write this idea.’](/assets/veritula-ai-label.png)

### New homepage for visitors

<https://veritula.com/>

-![Homepage 1](/assets/veritula-homepage-hero.png)+![Veritula’s new homepage, with the headline ‘Watch History’s Great Discussions Unfold’ over a photo of the Moon and a timeline of four chronicles](/assets/veritula-homepage-hero.png)

A scroll-through story of how criticism decides, discussion cards, the latest bounties, and a new footer.

-![Homepage 2](/assets/veritula-homepage-criticism-decides.png)
-![Homepage 3](/assets/veritula-homepage-discussions.png)
-![Homepage 4](/assets/veritula-homepage-bounties.png)
-![Homepage 5](/assets/veritula-homepage-footer.png)+![The homepage’s ‘Criticism Decides’ section, explaining when an idea is rationally adoptable with an example discussion](/assets/veritula-homepage-criticism-decides.png)
+![The homepage’s ‘Join a Discussion’ section, with cards for six ongoing discussions, each showing a small discussion tree](/assets/veritula-homepage-discussions.png)
+![The homepage’s bounties section, ‘Put a Price on Criticism’, listing three open bounties](/assets/veritula-homepage-bounties.png)
+![The homepage’s new footer, with counts of ideas, criticisms, and revisions, and a call to sign up](/assets/veritula-homepage-footer.png)

### Link previews

@@ -84,8 +84,8 @@ Ideas, discussions, bounties, and profiles get their own large preview cards whe

Unchanged parts collapse, code shows line numbers, and link and image changes show.

-![Diffs 1](/assets/veritula-diff-collapsed.png)
-![Diffs 2](/assets/veritula-diff-code.png)+![A diff with its unchanged parts collapsed, showing a deleted word in red](/assets/veritula-diff-collapsed.png)
+![A diff of Ruby code with line numbers, deleted lines in red and added lines in green](/assets/veritula-diff-code.png)

### Profile counts


Original · · View this version (v1)

# Four Great Debates in Science, Retold on Veritula

*Veritula changelog, Sept 30 – Oct 9*

Thanks to Claude, I’ve been able to make improvements to my site [Veritula](https://veritula.com) at an unprecedented rate. This past ~week alone, I’ve added features and fixed bugs that would have taken me at least several weeks to take care of manually. Claude also helped me write this post.

Veritula now tells four of science’s great debates as discussions: every idea, every criticism, and every answer, in the order they came. A timeline steps through each one, and at every step you see which ideas had no unanswered criticism. Each comes with portraits, interactive drawings, and profiles of the people in it. They’re read-only for now, and I plan to add more chronicles later.

<https://veritula.com/chronicles>

![Chronicles](/assets/veritula-chronicles.png)

## [Why Don’t We Feel the Earth Move?](https://veritula.com/discussions/why-don-t-we-feel-the-earth-move)

270 BCE–1927 · 12 events

If the Earth circles the Sun, the stars should seem to shift over the year. For two thousand years, nobody could see them shift. Follow the objections and answers from Aristarchus to the Sun’s own path around the Milky Way.

![Tycho finds no shift in the stars](/assets/veritula-chronicle-tycho.png)

## [How Mercury and Starlight Overthrew Newton](https://veritula.com/discussions/how-mercury-and-starlight-overthrew-newton)

1687–2020 · 10 events

Mercury’s orbit drifts a little more than Newton’s law allows. Astronomers searched for a hidden planet to explain it and found none. Einstein’s theory explained the drift, then faced a test it could have failed: the eclipse of 1919.

## [Wave or Particle? How Light Outgrew Both](https://veritula.com/discussions/wave-or-particle-how-light-outgrew-both)

1690–1997 · 12 events

Two beams of light can add up to darkness, something no stream of particles should do. Yet light knocks electrons out of metal the way particles would. See how physicists got from Huygens and Newton to quantum fields and the parallel universes David Deutsch argued for.

## [Was It in the Air? The Killers Too Small to See](https://veritula.com/discussions/was-it-in-the-air-the-killers-too-small-to-see)

1842–1962 · 9 events

Doctors blamed disease on foul air, and the idea of germs met objections at every step. In 1892, the chemist Max von Pettenkofer, aged 73, drank a culture of cholera germs in front of witnesses to show they couldn’t cause the disease on their own. He got off with diarrhea.

## Also new

### Visual discussion tree

<https://veritula.com/discussions/what-makes-one-idea-better-than-another>

Discussion and idea pages show a visual tree beside the text. A timeline steps through the discussion’s history, and the text follows it into the past. Arrow keys move it; on phones, a round button shows the tree.

![Visual discussion tree](/assets/veritula-visual-tree.png)

### Passkeys

Sign up and log in with a passkey, the default for new accounts. Accounts with one can remove their password. “Forgot password” is now “Can’t log in?”.

Set your passkey at <https://veritula.com/users/edit>

![Choosing a passkey at sign-up](/assets/veritula-passkey-signup.png)

### AI-assisted flag

Authors can mark ideas as AI-assisted with a checkbox.

![AI-assisted 1](/assets/veritula-ai-checkbox.png)
![AI-assisted 2](/assets/veritula-ai-label.png)

### New homepage for visitors

<https://veritula.com/>

![Homepage 1](/assets/veritula-homepage-hero.png)

A scroll-through story of how criticism decides, discussion cards, the latest bounties, and a new footer.

![Homepage 2](/assets/veritula-homepage-criticism-decides.png)
![Homepage 3](/assets/veritula-homepage-discussions.png)
![Homepage 4](/assets/veritula-homepage-bounties.png)
![Homepage 5](/assets/veritula-homepage-footer.png)

### Link previews

Ideas, discussions, bounties, and profiles get their own large preview cards when shared.

![A chronicle’s link preview](/assets/veritula-link-preview.png)

### Better diffs

Unchanged parts collapse, code shows line numbers, and link and image changes show.

![Diffs 1](/assets/veritula-diff-collapsed.png)
![Diffs 2](/assets/veritula-diff-code.png)

### Profile counts

Profile headers read like “21 ideas: 17 adoptable, 4 rejectable”.

![Profile counts](/assets/veritula-profile-counts.png)

### Copy links to versions

The idea menu copies a link to the version shown or to the latest one.

![The idea menu’s copy-link items](/assets/veritula-copy-link-menu.png)
Playing ~