Dennis Hackethal’s Blog

My blog about philosophy, coding, and anything else that interests me.

Tweets

An archive of my tweets and retweets through . They may be formatted slightly differently than on Twitter. API access has since gotten prohibitively expensive – I don't know whether or when I'll be able to update this archive.

But in case I will, you can subscribe via RSS – without a Twitter account. Rationale

@falibilista

I don't think Deutsch's sustainability critique applies to this pandemic as it stands.

Right, but why not?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@falibilista

No. I think it would have been reasonable to advise people to wear masks, keep a distance, stay at home, etc. Those willing to take the risk would then have been able to take it, and to continue working. Others could still have stayed home.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@falibilista

Are they in conflict?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tomhyde_

That sounds amazing. One thing I look forward to is the ability to temporarily turn off auditory and visual channels for a complete sensory-deprivation experience.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@falibilista

"Temporary" government measures often don't remain temporary because it's much harder to win back control once it's surrendered.

Lockdowns are like when children are grounded. Allegedly for their own good. Objectively disgraceful.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@falibilista

Those people don't work in a vacuum. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if their work would be greatly aided by having everyone else work normally. We cannot predict what discoveries might be made by others currently locked down that would help develop a vaccine.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@realchrisrufo @realDonaldTrump @RussVought45

You’re crushing it hard!!

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tomhyde_

Agreed. Though I love sleep, it’s one of the few areas in which our genes exert near-total control over us. Places a limit on how much progress one can make in a single period. And could still be optionally available once we transfer to machines!

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Lockdowns keep us from pursuing those things. Therefore, lockdowns are counterproductive in our fight against the virus—let alone utterly immoral.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Right there, through that one elegant paragraph, it becomes clear how much lockdown thinking is really static-society thinking. People are hoping that a lifestyle—lockdowns—will protect them. In fact, only the creation of knowledge and wealth and the freedom to pursue them can.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

"...But note that this lifestyle did not, when it was tried, prevent the Black Death. Nor would it cure cancer."

— David Deutsch, The Beginning of Infinity

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

"...A society which did this would not be able to afford the kind of scientific research that would lead to new [medicine]. Its members would hope that their lifestyle would protect them instead..."

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Prescient lines re the pandemic:

"The prophetic approach can see only what one might do to postpone disaster, namely improve sustainability: drastically reduce and disperse the population, make travel difficult, suppress contact between different geographical areas..."

👇

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@ABC

What’s the big deal? Even assuming animals are conscious, the animal picked up the cigarette itself and “decided” to smoke it. There was no coercion or cruelty. The worst that happened here was littering.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@BetterCallSaul

The winner takes Saul.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@WatchRatio

I saw this on my timeline.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

It's not quite new to see it seeping into tech, either—given the major tech companies' location and demographics, it's not surprising that they'd be left-leaning. But having political messages shoved down your throat while programming is a whole different ballpark. It's nasty.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Google and Apple are perhaps the two most powerful companies on the planet right now. They don't have to signal this stuff. I highly doubt anyone would stop buying their products for lack of such signals. Yet they signal it anyway. Which means they must actually believe it.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

...but it's much worse to see it seep into tech, an area normally so wonderfully devoid of messy human affairs, so egalitarian in nature (without trying to be). It's sad seeing this industry I love devolving.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

That's how pervasive the cancer that is social justice has become. It follows you into your professional life. I've always been aware that academia is politically motivated and left-leaning...

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

It's a bit like a plumber reaching for his hammer on the job and the hammer having a sticker on saying "black lives matter," reminding the plumber of the meme on the job.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

It is one thing to place political signals in ads, as Apple did today (twitter.com/dchackethal/st…; though even there I'd much rather they didn't). It is quite another to put it in the documentation.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Google knows this, of course. Yet that doesn't stop them from placing a banner at the top of every page in the documentation for one of their tools saying: "Google is committed to advancing racial equity for Black communities. See how."

developers.google.com/apps-script/re… https://t.co/qh56pPIy6z

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

That documentation is available online and searchable. While perusing the documentation, you're in programming mode. You don't think about political matters. You came there to solve a problem, to look something up. You don't want to be distracted by political messages.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

While programming, if you're using some tool you didn't develop yourself (which is frequently the case), it is common to go that tool's documentation to look up how things work. The documentation is a bit like an owner's manual. It contains technical information.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

apple.com/homepod-mini/

😔🤮 https://t.co/BE10TMbS9M

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@Buchpreis

Hoffentlich keins.

Es ist wirklich erstaunlich, wie viele Kommentare unter diesem Foto die Antifa gutheißen.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@n_iccolo

I'm still exploring this area myself, but I think when discussion, criticism, and persuasion are possible and effective, we should prefer them over penalty. Could there be exceptions? Maybe.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@SpaceX

Godspeed.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@ks445599

Yes, good point. Practically unfireable. Also because of public perception.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

I just learned that Spotify has a “Global Head of Diversity, Inclusion and Belonging.” It doesn’t get much more “feel good” than that. All they need now is a Global Head of Ponies and Warm, Fuzzy Feelings.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

The moral poverty of lockdowns, that is.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

It’s a start. No mention of the moral poverty, though. twitter.com/cowboyInNY/sta…

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

The coercive ideas surrounding the containment of COVID employ the same trick. If you resist being forced to stay at home, you're considered a grandma killer. Arguably, anti-rational ideas about the virus have spread much faster and are more harmful than the virus itself.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Once you understand this trick that such ideas use, you don't feel bad as easily anymore, and you'll have less of a problem criticizing them. The next step is to do so publicly, to help contain the spread of such ideas, and to show others they don't have to feel bad.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

There are ideas which, through their defining attribute of the opposition to something evil, make you feel bad if you question them (that includes BLM, Antifa, etc). Such ideas should make us extremely skeptical. Penalizing criticism is about as anti-rational as it gets.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@kreuzberged

We should be careful not to romanticize the horror that was Soviet Russia.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@kreuzberged

Comments on the original post indicate that this was propaganda, and the poster agrees.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@liberty_deity

It’s a bit ironic that this message would be presented in a classroom setting forced upon kids by the state in the first place.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

“People will die unless...” is easy to vary externally. twitter.com/DanielJHannan/…

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@asiramsa

Weihnachtsgans mit Klößen, Rotkraut und Soße!!

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@asiramsa

Schnitzel mit Preiselbeersoße & Kartoffelsalat. Schweinshaxe. Oder ist das alles österreichisch? So oder so könnte ich mich jedes Mal reinsetzen. Ach und Maultaschen. Königsberger Klopse...

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@MichaelPSenger

And hammer and sickle in the name 🤢🤮

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@traf

What site is that screenshot from, if I may ask?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@kreuzberged @AmRadDrehen

Wie schoen das damals war!

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@paulg

FWIW, many of those who are said to resist wearing masks actually just resist being forced to wear a mask. The difference is important because it brings out the real source of frustration and the actual point of contention: force vs persuasion.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@mgoldingmd @metaLulie

I'm curious, does the "induced" happiness wane over repeated applications?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@leeerob @prisma

Does prisma.post.findMany() send an XHR?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@mgoldingmd @ReachChristofer @Crit_Rat

Perhaps we are able to turn subconscious ideas into conscious ones through careful thinking, though. And then go from there.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@mgoldingmd @ReachChristofer @Crit_Rat

Ah, yes, and in that sense, death from earthquake is also caused by a lack of knowledge, of course. What I mean is some ideas may evolve completely subconsciously, and I'm unsure as to how much careful thinking could help tackle ideas we don't know we have.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

One of the better articles I’ve read on the lockdown issue.

One minor note: even if there were evidence that lockdowns work in terms of controlling the virus (the lack of which is rightly bemoaned), we’d still need a good moral explanation for why it’s okay to lock people down twitter.com/MichaelPSenger…

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@mgoldingmd @ReachChristofer @Crit_Rat

Yes, although I'm not sure I'd put it in terms of a lack of careful thinking. I wonder if sometimes bad ideas can evolve in minds undetected, and so careful thinking couldn't always help. Then some of them may be bad enough they lead to what we call "illness." What do you think?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tiptoptm

In that book, Deutsch gives a refutation of a similar idea which says that people acquire new behaviors by imitating them, which can't work because you need the idea/explanation of the behaviors to enact them in the first place. It has to happen in that order. Same with AGI.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tiptoptm

Well, AGI is a creative process. But overall, yes, I think so. + I'd add emphasis on not imitating humans. explanation > imitation

A useful rule of thumb from Deutsch's "The Beginning of Infinity": If we can already build it, it has nothing to do with intelligence.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tiptoptm

Without such an answer, advocating neural nets over some other arbitrary "learning" algorithm is irrational, because any of them might lead us to AGI.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tiptoptm

The difference is that evolution is creative, neural nets aren't. And before we dump millions into neural-net-based AGI research, shouldn't we first have an answer to the question: why and how would AGI arise from neural nets?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tiptoptm

There are self-replicating ideas in our minds as well, and all they "want" to do is spread, too, yet that's how we come up with solutions to problems. In evolution (mental or biological), solutions are always created without regard for the problem situation.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@tiptoptm

Because an explanation of the human mind is the program that's needed.

It's very rare to stumble upon an explanation by accident/by doing something completely different.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@danpayne1 @dvassallo

Instead of asking yourself, “how do I know if I’m choosing the right thing?”, ask yourself, “how can I make it as easy as possible to detect when I haven’t chosen the right thing, and then change paths accordingly?”

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@mgoldingmd @ReachChristofer @Crit_Rat

Got it, but... in the case of earthquakes, ideas seem to have nothing to do with it, whereas in the case of mental issues, it makes sense to me that they'd have something to do with it.

If ideas are software, couldn't bugs lead to symptoms we associate with mental illness?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Is there a no-go theorem à la Balinski and Young that mathematically proves that there can be no perfect representation in groups of people using a sufficient number of dimensions such as gender, race, age, etc?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Ein grosser Verlust im Kampf gegen Verfechter der "sozialen Gerechtigkeit" war der Tag, an dem der Duden das Wort "cisgender" uebernahm.

duden.de/rechtschreibun…

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@MatMcGann

I don’t think so, because the greater the danger, the easier it is to persuade people, and so no force is needed.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@MatMcGann

I think there are parallels there to the weakness of character of the people acquiescing in or even eagerly accepting government-enforced lockdowns.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@ReachChristofer @Crit_Rat @mgoldingmd

Why is that a worse explanation, and of what?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@Neuro_Skeptic

No, problems are, and in a broader sense creativity.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@ReachChristofer @Crit_Rat

I think what you’re describing would also be a software issue. Also, I’m not sure there is such a thing as a “fear center” and “object recognition center”—it’s all ideas about what to fear and what objects to recognize.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Erfolg, die, wenn sie ernst genommen wird und wie aus der Geschichte nur allzu gut bekannt ist, nur zu Zwangsenteignung und Gewalt fuehren kann.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Daher haengt die urspruengliche Frage “Koennen wir uns die Reichen noch leisten” nicht nur vom angeblichen (und nicht existenten) Nullsummenspiel der Wirtschaft ab, sondern hat eine ganz ueble Grundeinstellung gegenueber wirtschaftlicher Taetigkeit und dem wirtschaftlichen...

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Die Vorstellung, dass die Wirtschaft angeblich ein Nullsummenspiel ist, hat schon zu viel Intoleranz und Leid gefuehrt, weil dann die Frage ist, auf wessen Kosten Fortschritt gemacht werden soll, und wem man Geld wegnehmen darf (den Reichen).

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Er ist das Resultat kreativer Arbeit und Zusammenarbeit und erfordert keine Kosten anderer. Die Wirtschaft ist kein Nullsummenspiel – da wird staendig etwas Neues erschaffen.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Es kann deshalb nicht stimmen, weil Reichtum nicht durch Umverteilung (von zukuenftig Armen zu zuekuenftig Reichen oder wie auch immer) erschaffen werden kann. Reichtum entsteht durch kreatives Schaffen ex nihilo.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Damit Ihr Zweifel stimmt, muesste man also irgendwie zeigen, dass Reichtum nicht erlangt werden koennte, ohne dass das auf Kosten anderer geschieht. Das kann aber nicht stimmen.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Um zu diesem Zweifel zu gelangen, muessen Sie also irgendeine Erklaerung gehabt haben (die ueber bloße Postulate aus der Literatur hinausgeht), von der Sie zu wissen meinen, dass Reichtum nur auf Kosten anderer erlangt werden kann.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Dass Sie kein Fachmann sind, macht uebrigens ueberhaupt nichts. Ich will mal versuchen, die Lage zu erklaeren. Sie zweifelten urspruenglich an meiner Aussage, dass der Reichtum eines anderen einen nichts koste.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Auch Bauarbeiter koennen sich ein Haus bauen, wenn sie den dafuer notwendigen Wohlstand erreicht haben (oder es finanziert kriegen). Und auch dieses Beispiel erklaert nicht, inwiefern Reichtum nur auf Kosten anderer erreicht werden koennte.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Angenommen, es ginge nicht ohne diese Mechanismen (was die auch immer sein moegen). Dann stellt sich erneut die Frage: Wieso muesste der eine arm werden, damit der andere reich werden kann?

Das ist uebrigens keine rhetorische Frage, sondern sie wendet sich direkt an Sie.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Naja, das ist ja nur die gleiche Behauptung, nur anders ausgedrückt. Also bleibt die Frage: warum ist das angeblich so, dass einer nur auf Kosten anderer reich werden kann?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@CyberKulak

Yes, instead of "kids," I should have said "kids and teens" or something along those lines. Basically everyone living at home having to bend to the will of their parent(s).

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@mgoldingmd @Crit_Rat

I wonder if perhaps it's a bit like peacock tails in the biosphere—they bog the animal down in some ways, but the adaption managed to spread anyway. If an idea triggering a hallucination can spread through a mind, it will do just that.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@michaelerich5 @b_hasanni

Weil...?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@b_hasanni @michaelerich5

Ja, und das konnte man schon immer, denn der Reichtum eines anderen kostet einen nichts.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

RT @ChipkinLogan:
As part of my constructor theory interview series, here's my chat with David Deutsch @DavidDeutschOxf about Constructor T…

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@SwipeWright

Why not blame both?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@DrIbram @TheRevAl

Aren’t you a martyr! You’re lying. It’s clear this is at least in part about you.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@frictionalgames

Only problem is, C++ code is scarier looking than the monsters in the game ;-)

Kidding, of course—this is awesome.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@EyalShay2

I imagine so.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@dvassallo

Yes, and the need for certainty is what discourages many from ever starting a business.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@amitcc

I think you're right, calling it the main reason might be too much.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Conjecture: the main reason so many adults have trouble sleeping is because of trauma from forced bedtimes when they were kids.

Any refutations?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@MichaelPSenger @WillowWyse

The oldest tweet I could find with this text is this one: twitter.com/mhdksafa/statu…

Maybe that tweet started it? Is it a coincidence that the tweet's author, @mhdksafa, seems to work for the UN?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@MatMcGann

I’m guessing he’s somewhat widely read there. It wasn’t required reading for me—I think I first found one of his books in my mom’s bookshelf, then bought more later.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@RichardDawkins

The opposite question seems more puzzling to me: how could one possibly raise happy, moral children with religion?!

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@MatMcGann

Haffner’s books played a major role in my learning about the Nazis as a teenager growing up in Germany. Highly recommend his books.

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@Hukkinen

If your application requires AGI but you haven’t built it, you haven’t succeeded.

That’s not to mention that AGI, like any other person, would need to consent to its “application.”

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

@Hukkinen

Enough for what purpose?

@dchackethal · · Show · Open on Twitter

Search tweets

/
/mi
Accepts a case-insensitive POSIX regular expression. Most URLs won’t match. Tweets may contain raw markdown characters, which are not displayed.
Clear filters